Beyond the Paradox: A Response to McKinsey’s ‘Agentic AI Advantage’ for the M365 Enterprise

Beyond the Paradox: A Response to McKinsey’s ‘Agentic AI Advantage’ for the M365 Enterprise

Summary

In response to McKinsey's "gen AI paradox," this paper argues that Microsoft 365 customers are stalled in part because legacy "Static Governance" prevents the secure external collaboration required for high-value AI agents. The solution includes adopting a "Trusted Collaboration" philosophy by weaving the eSHARE Trusted Collaboration Fabric into the M365 tenant. This provides the intelligent guardrails and end-to-end observability needed to finally build trust, scale agentic AI, and unlock its true competitive advantage.

Introduction: Acknowledging McKinsey's Paradox in M365

In its pivotal report, "Seizing the agentic AI advantage," McKinsey & Company articulates a critical challenge facing the modern enterprise: the "gen AI paradox". Despite nearly eight in ten companies reporting the use of generative AI, an equal number sees no significant bottom-line impact. For the vast majority of Microsoft 365 customers, this diagnosis is intimately familiar. While enterprise-wide copilots have scaled quickly, McKinsey correctly notes that about 90 percent of more transformative, function-specific "vertical" use cases remain stuck in pilot mode.

The report posits that AI agents—capable of automating complex, multi-step processes—are the key to breaking out of this paradox and unlocking scalable impact. We agree. However, the report’s most crucial insight is that the "bigger challenge" won't be technical. It will be human: earning trust, driving adoption, and establishing the right governance.

For M365 customers, this is the heart of the issue. The reason transformative AI agents are stalled is a direct collision between the dynamic potential of Agentic Collaboration and an insidious, deeply entrenched adversary: Static Governance. This is especially true the moment a workflow needs to cross organizational boundaries.

The Enemy McKinsey Identified: Static Governance

McKinsey’s report details the risks of uncontrolled autonomy, agent sprawl, and the need for a new architectural paradigm. We believe these are symptoms of a single, underlying enemy that prevents M365 customers from realizing the full value of their AI investments: Static Governance.

Static Governance is the status quo—a broken model of fragmented technologies and manual, context-blind security policies that fail to keep pace with human interaction, let alone autonomous agents. In the M365 ecosystem, this enemy creates innovation paralysis. Consider these common scenarios:

• An AI agent designed to accelerate client onboarding needs to securely collect financial documents from an external party. Static Governance forces it into a clunky, insecure email workflow, creating friction and undermining the very efficiency it was designed to provide.

• An agent built to coordinate a multi-partner supply chain needs to share logistics data. Static Governance, with its clumsy VPNs and insecure file-sharing links, either blocks the collaboration entirely or forces an exception that bypasses security, creating unacceptable risk.

This forces M365 customers into the two impossible choices McKinsey’s findings imply: lock down AI agents with restrictive controls that nullify their value or create governance exceptions that destroy trust and invite breaches. Static Governance is the primary reason the trust, adoption, and governance that McKinsey calls for remains out of reach.

The Movement McKinsey Calls For: Trusted Collaboration

To defeat this enemy, organizations must join a movement that directly answers McKinsey’s call to action. The solution lies in a new philosophy:  

Trusted Collaboration. This movement rejects the outdated, on-premises assumption that files must physically leave an organization's control to be shared. Instead, it is built on first principles designed to enable the scalable, governed AI that McKinsey envisions:

• Keep Data Contained: Share links, not files, to maintain a single source of truth within M365, improving the accuracy of both humans and AI agents.

• Deliver Guardrails, Not Barriers: Implement flexible, dynamic security policies that adapt to the nuances of agentic workflows without creating the manual bottlenecks that plague Static Governance.

• Integrate Natively into Workflows: Embed secure sharing directly where humans and agents collaborate in M365 to eliminate friction.

• Ensure End-to-End Observability: Capture a complete, immutable audit trail of all data interactions to build the trust that McKinsey identifies as a critical human challenge.

The Solution for M365: Weaving the eSHARE Trusted Collaboration Fabric

McKinsey calls for a new "agentic AI mesh" and a shift to "industrialized, scalable delivery". For M365 customers, this abstract concept must become a concrete reality. The solution is to weave a Trusted Collaboration Fabric directly into the M365 environment—a flexible, strong, and interconnected foundation for governance.

eSHARE is the platform that weaves this fabric, directly addressing the challenges in McKinsey’s report and operationalizing the principles of Trusted Collaboration within M365.

• Solve for Governed Autonomy: McKinsey highlights the need to control agent autonomy and prevent sprawl. The eSHARE Trusted Collaboration Fabric provides Contextual Policy Enforcement with intelligent guardrails. It automatically applies Microsoft Purview sensitivity labels at the point of sharing, ensuring an agent collaborating with an external partner adheres to data handling policies in real time. This delivers the governed autonomy McKinsey calls for.

• Scale Vertical Use Cases: The report laments that 90% of high-value vertical use cases are stalled, many of which involve external stakeholders. eSHARE's Native Workflow Integrations and Bring Your Own Identity (BYOI) capability make secure external agentic collaboration frictionless. An agent can now securely collect sensitive documents from thousands of clients without requiring a single guest account, finally allowing these critical use cases to move from pilot to production.

• To Build Trust Through Observability: McKinsey correctly states that earning trust is paramount. eSHARE provides the necessary proof. Its commitment to Secure Data Containment ensures all collaboration revolves around a single source of truth in M365. Its Observability and Analytics capability then capture every interaction in a defensible audit log, providing the transparent record required to build trust between humans, agents, and external partners.

Conclusion: From Paradox to Performance

McKinsey’s "gen AI paradox" is not a technology problem; it’s a governance problem. For Microsoft 365 customers, this paradox persists because the enemy of Static Governance creates a trust deficit that paralyzes high-value AI initiatives.

The solution is to join the movement for Trusted Collaboration by weaving the eSHARE Trusted Collaboration Fabric into your M365 tenant. By doing so, organizations can move beyond experimentation to the industrialized, scalable delivery of AI agents that work securely across organizational boundaries. These will be the winning organizations that McKinsey describes—the ones who successfully harness AI's collaborative power to create exponential returns and define the future of their industries.

‍